What’s Cooking at Delancey Tavern, Downtown Durham’s New Neighborhood Spot

Share This!

Delancey Tavern pairs inventive dishes and thoughtful design in a historic building in Durham’s Central Park District, creating a restaurant built around good food and generous hospitality

New restaurant in downtown Durham

By Hannah Lee | Photography by John Michael Simpson

Surely, the kitchen staff thought, there’d been a mistake. Some computer error, or a waiter accidentally delivering the same order twice.

But, no. On a recent Monday night at Delancey Tavern – one of downtown’s buzziest new restaurants since its much-anticipated February opening – two diners did indeed hunker down at the bar and order four servings of fried lobster and shrimp dumplings. Yes, four. Kyle Miller, one of Delancey’s co-owners, joked with the couple when he dropped off the fourth order that the kitchen was running out.

“They told me that they actually came back in specifically because they had wanted to get the shrimp and lobster dumplings on Sunday night – but we had already sold out,” Kyle says. “So they came back the very next day to try them.”

It’s a revealing look into the role Delancey has quickly carved out in the Central Park District – and in Durham’s broader dining scene.

Kyle and co-owner Tracy Hancock, who also owns neighboring Hutchins Garage, began dreaming about Delancey nearly two years before construction started. Their vision was straightforward: Create an establishment that feels approachable while delivering consistently satisfying meals at a fair price.

“These days, you can spend the majority of a $20 bill on lunch and sometimes get something that’s not worth $20 – and it’s very frustrating,” Tracy says. “It was really important for us that the food that we put out represented a good value for what we were asking people to pay for it.”

As longtime Durhamites, Kyle and Tracy also understood what locals crave from a neighborhood restaurant: versatility.

Delancey can be a destination for a dressed-up dinner with a reservation – or the kind of spot you wander into from down the street and still score an exceptional meal at the bar.

Dishes include new American classics, like Delancey’s bestselling burger and fries – which executive chef Derek Pierce confidently calls the Triangle’s best (and crispiest) – but there are also more adventurous options, such as the aforementioned dumplings and their accompanying peach chowchow that blends Chinese and Southern cuisine. The rest of the menu reads like a hug from grandma: Deviled egg dip arrives with fried Ritz crackers, while the “Chicken Cooked Under a Brick” revives a throwback recipe from former Italian restaurant Popʼs.

Tracy, who grew up in Durham, remembers appreciating the way Pop’s struck that same balance between an easygoing atmosphere and seriously good cooking; he hopes Delancey can live in that same crossover space. After one visit, it’s easy to envision that happening.

Cocktail lounge in downtown Durham
Upstairs, thoughtful details reflect the eye of Jennifer Noone, co-owner Malachy Nooneʼs wife, who Tracy says is “responsible for everything beautiful in here.”

Floor-to-ceiling windows along the front of the restaurant beckon for passersby to peer inside – and perhaps wave to Kyle, who lives within walking distance of the Geer Street spot. The interior design preserves the building’s industrial character as a former car dealership and auto supply shop while giving the dining room its own distinct personality.

During the day, those expansive windows flood the main dining area with sunlight, but there’s also a moodier mezzanine upstairs where guests can slink off to sip on one of Delancey’s signature cocktails, including the gin-based Water Lily. After all, Delancey’s intention is to offer a little something for everyone – by design.

Share This!

Posted in

Durham Magazine

Newsletters-Thumbnail
Stay Connected

Sign Up for Our Newsletters

Your guide to food, fun and what's new across the Triangle – straight to your inbox.

error: Content is protected !!
Scroll to Top